Totty's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[A Walk in Town]

Honestly,

...This whole ninja/samurai THING has been re-hashed so many times, there's no real reason to criticize it. Instead, I suggest you put down your anime for a few seconds and pick up an American animation book. One that talks about timing and weight and PROPORTION AND CONSISTENCY, Oh god yes, two very important things to remember for successful animation. The reason I'm putting it this way, is because I saw this on the frontpage, and I think that you have a lot of potential with your animation. I say do some character studies, a lot of figure drawing, and work on simple animations like balls bouncing and whatnot. Focus mostly on the animation, and drawing, and less on camera angles and 'being cool'.

Keep workin', I see good things coming your way.
Aaaand that's my monthly critique.

["Sasper" Episode 2]

Hahaha

Funny shit marc, glad to see new stuff from you!

[Banana Nut Bread]

haha sweet.

Now here's nice little thing guys have made, nattle unt monkerton!
I treasure it.

[No Man's Land Flash Anime]

Good...but very long.

This was decent. It was exactly what you advertised it to be, a flash anime. I liked the illustrative side of it, but there really wasn't a hell of a lot of animation. Not that that bothers me, it just seemed to me that for the length of the cartoon, very little happened, wether that was intentional or not.

[Mutilation Contrainte]

This was awesome.

Really nice work. A real break from the norm.

[Autumn Tree]

Hmm.

While I hold AITD as one of the better NG artists, I am confused as to the message behind this film. While I appreciate all the artistic ideas and efforts in it, I think this kind of representation of events is a little strange, especially when dealing with this kind of material. What I'm saying is, in filmmaking, with this kind of situation, you can't let the film be self-explainatory if there is no clear message behind it. If you weren't trying to make a statement, what was the point of the film? I'm not trying to aggrovate or stir up a beehive, I'm just posing questions that maybe next time you could ask yourselves before making something like this.

[The Mad Cow]

HAH

Freaking funny! Right up my alley. Anyway, funny idea, nicely executed and animated.

Right on, booga.

[-FILLED-]

Very cool

Original! I am really unsure as to the way you did this, I'm not so familiar with 3D animation, but I was pretty impressed with this!

Nice little flick!

[Braindead]

SIMPLE LINE SERIES KNOCKOFF.

GAH. I'm tired of people ripping off the simple line series! Please do something original, or pick different music at the very least!

To see what I'm talking about, search for "A SIMPLE LINE".

Watch #7. Yeah.

Redshift responds:

Shut up! I'm trying to get better at animating by animating random things. I never intended to copy Simple line. And I was already half way through this when I saw simple line 7. So if I change music it would sync up. I hate people like you.

[Link vs Darklink]

Ehhh.

Besides the fact that you traced the horse graphics, I suppose some of the animation was decent.